| Award Show | The 1995 ESPY Awards |
| Deion Sanders | ||
| Jon Bon Jovi | ... | Andre Agassi |
| Manute Bol | ||
| Ellen Cleghorne | ... | Florence Griffith Joiner |
| Chris Elliott | ... | Chris Berman |
| Chris Farley | ... | John Goodman |
| Janeane Garofalo | ... | Susan Sarandon |
| Laura Kightlinger | ... | Brooke Shields |
| Mark McKinney | ... | Tim Robbins |
| Tim Meadows | ... | Mike Espy |
| Jay Mohr | ... | Dick Vitale |
| Adam Sandler | ... | Bobcat Goldthwait |