| Sketch | Magic Fish Town Meeting |
| Luke Perry | ... | townsperson |
| Dana Carvey | ... | townsperson |
| Tom Davis | ... | townsperson |
| Chris Farley | ... | reverend |
| Phil Hartman | ... | mayor |
| Tim Meadows | ... | Bill Simpson |
| Mike Myers | ... | townsperson |
| Kevin Nealon | ... | Harry |
| Adam Sandler | ... | townsperson |
| Rob Schneider | ... | Rick Harris |
| Julia Sweeney | ... | townsperson |
| Christine Zander | ... | townsperson |
| Andy Murphy | ... | townsperson |