| Sketch | Substitute Judge |
| Rodney Dangerfield | ... | Dick Hertz |
| Peter Aykroyd | ... | juror |
| Jane Curtin | ... | stenographer |
| Jim Downey | ... | juror |
| Brian Doyle-Murray | ... | Milton Crotchie |
| Tom Gammill | ... | juror |
| Yvonne Hudson | ... | spectator |
| Franne Lee | ... | juror |
| Garrett Morris | ... | bailiff |
| Bill Murray | ... | attorney |
| Laraine Newman | ... | attorney |
| Sarah Paley | ... | juror |
| Max Pross | ... | juror |
| Gilda Radner | ... | wife |
| Karen Roston | ... | spectator |
| Paul Shaffer | ... | spectator |
| Harry Shearer | ... | judge |
| Liz Welch | ... | spectator |
| Alan Zweibel | ... | spectator |
| Andy Murphy | ... | juror |
| Rob Morrow | ... | juror |