| Show | New York Morning News |
| Ayo Edebiri | ... | wife |
| Mikey Day | ... | guy |
| Andrew Dismukes | ... | guy |
| Chloe Fineman | ... | girl |
| Heidi Gardner | ... | girl |
| Marcello Hernández | ... | Hannah's husband |
| James Austin Johnson | ... | husband |
| Punkie Johnson | ... | girl |
| Molly Kearney | ... | Hannah Jennings |
| Michael Longfellow | ... | Keith Michaels |
| Ego Nwodim | ... | girl |
| Sarah Sherman | ... | girl |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | guy |
| Chloe Troast | ... | girl |
| Devon Walker | ... | guy |
| Bowen Yang | ... | Danny Love |
| Martin Herlihy | ... | guy |