| Sketch | Love at First Sight |
| Chance the Rapper | ... | William |
| Beck Bennett | ... | bartender |
| Heidi Gardner | ... | Beth |
| Cecily Strong | ... | Jennifer |
| Chloe Fineman | ... | waitress |
| Ego Nwodim | ... | friend |
| Zana Markelson | ... | patron |
| Keo Nozari | ... | patron |
| Rebecca Sussman | ... | patron |