| Show | Braxton High School Prom Red Carpet |
| Keegan-Michael Key | ... | Jacob Shneeb |
| Beck Bennett | ... | guy |
| Aidy Bryant | ... | girl |
| Pete Davidson | ... | Mr. Miller |
| Mikey Day | ... | guy |
| Heidi Gardner | ... | Katie Stervack |
| Kyle Mooney | ... | Danny Fuge |
| Ego Nwodim | ... | Lexi |
| Chris Redd | ... | guy |
| Melissa Villaseñor | ... | Michelle Shugian |
| Andrew Dismukes | ... | Ted Vinaigrette |
| Chloe Fineman | ... | date |
| Bowen Yang | ... | P.J. Rube |
| Steve Higgins | ... | announcer Voice |