| Sketch | Lights Out “Different in the Dark” |
| Jennifer Garner | ... | girl in the dark |
| Jimmy Fallon | ... | guy |
| Tracy Morgan | ... | Ernie in the light |
| Maya Rudolph | ... | Ernie in the dark |
| Fred Armisen | ... | girl in the light |
| Seth Meyers | ... | Davey |
| Scott Wainio | ... | patron |
| Michael Delaney | ... | patron |